Upload
Login or register

mattymc

Last status update:
-
Date Signed Up:2/05/2011
Last Login:9/29/2016
Stats
Comment Ranking:#2041
Highest Content Rank:#2201
Highest Comment Rank:#599
Content Thumbs: 5296 total,  6044 ,  748
Comment Thumbs: 27134 total,  29413 ,  2279
Content Level Progress: 25% (25/100)
Level 150 Content: Faptastic → Level 151 Content: Faptastic
Comment Level Progress: 94.9% (949/1000)
Level 321 Comments: Covered In Thumbs → Level 322 Comments: Covered In Thumbs
Subscribers:0
Content Views:172112
Times Content Favorited:119 times
Total Comments Made:4627
FJ Points:27263

latest user's comments

#9 - Or Or Or Tarkin was an arrogant moron who refused to …  [+] (2 replies) 08/06/2016 on The Death Star was an... +17
#14 - anon (08/07/2016) [-]
That's great fuel for a conspiracy theory.
#21 - mattymc (08/07/2016) [-]
yeah and i know the name of the ringleader
George Lucas
#29 - Thats's so wrong it's bait-tier  [+] (4 replies) 08/05/2016 on What If? 0
User avatar
#30 - tanuith (08/05/2016) [-]
Perhaps, it is Its been awhile since i watched the movie. Last time i checked however he showed her Alderaan and said that bad things would happen if she lied. She said Dantooine but Dantooine's rebel base was abandoned for years and the empire already checked there. As a consequence of Leia's actions the planet went zap. But then again It is possible I am wrong due to having not watched the original in awhile
User avatar
#37 - mindyourownbusines (08/05/2016) [-]
That still puts the hostage taker (Vader/the Empire) in the wrong. It's like if kidnapped you and told you to tell me where your kids, parents, and/or significant other was, or there will be consequences.

If you lied to save them and I blew up a primary school, you wouldn't be to blame for it. It would still be my choice to kill them even if I tried to shift the blame onto your choice. You know?
User avatar
#38 - tanuith (08/05/2016) [-]
Yeah you are probably right. I just find that the rebellion has been doing some questionable stuff as well but then again they don't show you that directly in the movies but rather the back lore things the studio made. and even then they still keep their theme of the rebels are better.
#44 - mattymc (08/05/2016) [-]
Call it High Sci-fi (similar to High Fantasy) there are relatively clear lines between good and evil and good is supposed to win in the end

If you want Dark Sci-fi, read some 40k novels, some of them are very well written
#25 - How many people were on peaceful, weaponless Alderaan?  [+] (10 replies) 08/05/2016 on What If? +7
User avatar
#28 - tanuith (08/05/2016) [-]
Leia's lie killed Alderaan. Vader told her what would happen if she pulled some selfish shit like that... The empire wanted to fix the insurrection. The insurrection was willing to murder millions to be petty anarchists.
User avatar
#51 - therealtjthemedic (08/05/2016) [-]
I'm pretty sure the death star killed alderaan.
User avatar
#34 - huntergriff (08/05/2016) [-]
Like...Tarkin did it for shits n giggles. He didn't even know she lied until after he sent a team out to dantooine...so...yeah, alderaan was doomed anyway.
User avatar
#35 - tanuith (08/05/2016) [-]
Well Rip i guess :/
User avatar
#33 - huntergriff (08/05/2016) [-]
Alderaan was doomed anyway whether or not she did lie.
#29 - mattymc (08/05/2016) [-]
Thats's so wrong it's bait-tier
User avatar
#30 - tanuith (08/05/2016) [-]
Perhaps, it is Its been awhile since i watched the movie. Last time i checked however he showed her Alderaan and said that bad things would happen if she lied. She said Dantooine but Dantooine's rebel base was abandoned for years and the empire already checked there. As a consequence of Leia's actions the planet went zap. But then again It is possible I am wrong due to having not watched the original in awhile
User avatar
#37 - mindyourownbusines (08/05/2016) [-]
That still puts the hostage taker (Vader/the Empire) in the wrong. It's like if kidnapped you and told you to tell me where your kids, parents, and/or significant other was, or there will be consequences.

If you lied to save them and I blew up a primary school, you wouldn't be to blame for it. It would still be my choice to kill them even if I tried to shift the blame onto your choice. You know?
User avatar
#38 - tanuith (08/05/2016) [-]
Yeah you are probably right. I just find that the rebellion has been doing some questionable stuff as well but then again they don't show you that directly in the movies but rather the back lore things the studio made. and even then they still keep their theme of the rebels are better.
#44 - mattymc (08/05/2016) [-]
Call it High Sci-fi (similar to High Fantasy) there are relatively clear lines between good and evil and good is supposed to win in the end

If you want Dark Sci-fi, read some 40k novels, some of them are very well written