and star wars is excellent even if you only see - #92169652 added by Mr Ronok at What if?

#21 - Mr Ronok

Reply +63 123456789123345869

(05/13/2013) [-]

that makes sense if you look at some movie adaptions

#157 to #21 - CupcakeMaster

Reply +3 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

What are you talking about? There was no Eragon movie.

#121 to #21 - yourmomisaslut

Reply +4 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

mfw when there eragon are fans up in site

#193 to #121 - Crusader

Reply +1 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

mfw there are asshole fans like pedgalad who nitpick about **** and can't think critically about what people say in their comments and then try to insult
But you're good, you are a cool guy

#77 to #21 - samxdaxman

Reply 0 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

The only thing that was just as off key as this movie was the Avatar movie and the Percy Jackson movie.

#49 to #21 - cantfindausername

Reply 0 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

I don't like to hate things... Why did you remind me of that awful, awful movie adaptation?

#48 to #21 - graysonschultz

Reply +6 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

that was my favorite book series of all time, i was actually excited when i saw the trailers and i went to see it and its was just so goddam bad it wasnt anything close to the book

#39 to #21 - whycanticaps

Reply +10 123456789123345869

(05/13/2013) [-]

Hey. Hey. You. That's right. I'm talking to you. Here I am, minding my own business, when I scroll down from this content, and I see your post. This Eragon post. Mr Ronoks post. The post that immediately filled me with such rage that I had to go find my Eragon book series, and cuddle them and assure them that they will not be abused like that again. You've brought up some painful memories. The movie was awful. In fact, there was no movie. Only a giant steaming pile of turd with some actors thrown in it

#196 to #39 - Crusader

Reply 0 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

My friends and I made a 30 minute video that summarized Eragon.
I used it for film class, they used it for drama, it was decent for the fact that it was basically all on a go pro, but it was still more accurate than the hollywood version

#26 to #21 - organiclead

Reply -18 123456789123345869

(05/13/2013) [-]

But the book was also crap.

#36 to #26 - defacedcreeper

Reply +10 123456789123345869

(05/13/2013) [-]

#43 to #36 - organiclead

Reply -11 123456789123345869

(05/13/2013) [-]

Seriously, it was. It was a tale about a Gary Stu getting everything given to him on a silver platter and being told how special he was for being at the right place at the right time on several occasions. It was Twilight for boys.

#70 to #43 - defacedcreeper

Reply +6 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

0/10 try harder faggot... whinny bitch

#50 to #43 - cantfindausername

Reply +4 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

Except not.

#58 to #50 - organiclead

Reply -8 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

I'm talking about the first book alone. I didn't get passed it because the first book was crap. We got Eragon, a farmer boy who just happened to find a dragon egg that just happened to be teleported in that location by an elven princess who just happened to have a mentor around to teach him and just happened not to be home when his uncle was killed who then was drug on a journey until his mentor died, then was lead and saved by Murtagh and had pretty much everything done for him by the end of the book. Even the climatic final battle was someone else doing all the work and him getting all of the credit for it. It's Star Wars with dragons.

#67 to #58 - Crusader

Reply +12 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

If you read past the first book you would realize how that stuff happened.
Brom was Eragon's father, staying there to watch over Eragon as he grew up, so that wasn't random
Arya meant to send it the egg to Brom, as he was the only person they could trust with it's safe keeping, but the magic sent it to his son, Eragon, so that wasn't random
Saphira flew Eragon away into the mountains when the Ra'Zac attacked the farm, so that wasn't random
Murtagh was following them long before when Brom died
Not to mention Eragon was all of 16 at the time, so he couldn't exactly be told to do everything, he was still learning, all he knew about was hunting and farming.
The final battle was a teenager going up against one of the most powerful beings on in the story alone and then being saved by an explosion

OH MY, it's star wars with dragons, how long did it take you to figure that out you literary genious? You must be so capable of seeing further into the author's thought process than everyone else, it's not as if it's blatantly obvious with character archetypes or political scenarios.

You're entire analysis is done without even completing the story, it's like saying star wars is bad after watching Episode 4

#180 to #67 - dkillakai

Reply +2 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

Actually the elundari meddled with Arya's magic, sending the egg off course to Eragon, rather than Brom, just as they fixed his back and finished his physical adaptation to being a rider

#195 to #180 - Crusader

Reply 0 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

So that was them, I honestly thought that the magic itself changed his appearance and that Arya just messed up.
Learn something new everyday.
Am I the only one that was kind of sad that the vault of souls wasn't that giant mountain in the middle of the desert?

#97 to #67 - Mr Ronok

Reply 0 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

and star wars is excellent even if you only see episode 4. and honestly, the only book that lines up with star wars that closely is the first one. the rest kinda taper off on the whole star wars thing

#100 to #97 - Crusader

Reply +1 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

Kind of, but it's still there, the dude becomes really important in the rebels, goes off to an old decrepit teacher to learn, said teacher then dies.
He learns his "father" was the evil dude's right hand man, secret sibling, super rare sword from his "father" that is given to him by the wise old mentor
The outlaw best bud and the non-human companion
Romance with a princess
Black dude is important but kind of a dick
A bunch of short guys decide to help out
There's a lot more

#155 to #100 - pedgalad

-2 123456789123345869

has deleted their comment [-]

#194 to #155 - Crusader

Reply +1 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

Not to mention that the "rare sword" was in all stories, but only in his possession for the first 2, much like Luke's Lightsaber.
Both came from extremely remote regions after being dropped off with their uncle and aunt after the "death" of their parents.
Antagonist's soldiers come and destroy the farm they grew up on and kill their uncle.
They spend the first part of their stories simply traveling to the remote rebel headquarters, only to have a giant fight that is ended with an explosion.
The second leg of their journey is all about them learning and training and suddenly they have to travel a great distance, just to end up in the middle of a battle where they have to fight someone much better than, only to be beaten and have the "truth" about their father's revealed, while losing their weapon.

Not to mention at the end of the whole war there is a massive explosion of nuclear proportions in which they have to make a speedy escape, and then they go off to teach people and change the code from what it was originally to what the world can actually use.

#192 to #155 - Crusader

Reply +1 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

Hey *******, if you look at my other comments, I said that Brom was his father, the reason I put quotation marks around "father" was that it wasn't actually his father and only who he thought was the father.
And how he dies doesn't matter, it's still a parallel to Star Wars.
1 - I know more about Eragon and Star Wars than is healthy or natural, so how about you sit down and shut up
2 - Don't make false accusations, I neither look at furry or go to **** for my pornography
3 - Quit being an uptight douche

#22 to #21 - thereoncewasaman

Reply +16 123456789123345869

(05/13/2013) [-]

Oh dear god don't remind me of that movie. I love that book series so much but they ****** up the movie unbelievably bad. I say it rivals Avatar in worst book to movie adaptations.

#40 to #22 - whycanticaps

Reply +5 123456789123345869

(05/13/2013) [-]

I wanted to cry after first seeing it. I had to turn it off because it was that awful

#38 to #22 - arkfire

Reply +12 123456789123345869

(05/13/2013) [-]

There isn't an avatar movie.

#177 to #38 - TwistedBamboozler

Reply +1 123456789123345869

(05/14/2013) [-]

just like there isn't a dragon ball movie . . . right?