If you actually watched the movie you'd know that they - #91333088 added by plainarcane at LotR: Just logical people

#3 - plainarcane**User deleted account**

Reply+73

(05/03/2013)[-]

If you actually watched the movie you'd know that they had no other choice but to take the mines.

#140 to #3 - anon id: cbf34fcb

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

Blatantly untrue, at least in the movie. The decision was between Moria and the Gap of Rohan, the problem with the Gap being that it took them "too close to Isengard". But seeing as they eventually fought the Uruk-Hai anyways, without Gandalf, that ended up being of little concern.

But yes, I imagine if Gandalf had mentioned the armies of goblins and the giant fire demon then Frodo might have chosen the Gap.

#106 to #3 - erethilful

Reply-2

(05/04/2013)[-]

If you actually think logically, you'd know that they would use those birds to fly into mordor.

#44 to #3 - anon id: 1309590a

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

(what about the eagles flying them?)

#25 to #3 - beren [OP]

Reply+2

(05/04/2013)[-]

Bitch do you SEE my profile name?

#48 to #25 - elielentir

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

where's Luthien?

#118 to #48 - beren [OP]

Reply+1

(05/04/2013)[-]

There has been no Luthien. At least, not since the accident...

#172 to #118 - elielentir

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

Yeah sorry about the hand...

#83 to #48 - ljxjlos

Reply+3

(05/04/2013)[-]

Well, If Beren had spent all his time on the Internet instead of wandering the woods, stealing Silmaril and all this Stuff, like this Beren here, there would be no Luthien for him.

#7 to #3 - Awesomenessniss

Reply+31

(05/04/2013)[-]

If you actually read the book you'd know that even better.

#92 to #7 - xzynth

Reply+12

(05/04/2013)[-]

I wish I could..

#53 to #7 - clockworkmage

Reply+1

(05/04/2013)[-]

Every time someone reads the original book, Christopher Tolkien murders a son as tribute to the Sun god.

#143 to #53 - Awesomenessniss

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

Totally worth it.

#39 to #7 - ninjastarthrow

Reply+4

(05/04/2013)[-]

No one read the books. I have four friends who enjoy LoTR but I'm the only one who ever read them all. Not gonna lie, The Hobbit was my favorite.

#122 to #39 - cyanidesandvich

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

i haven't "read" the books, but i listen to the unabridged audio-book whilst playing WoW

#76 to #39 - joehue

Reply+7

(05/04/2013)[-]

Agreed, I mean a lot of people have read the books(Still very popular), but a good chunk that watched the movies haven't read even touched the books.

It's a shame too since they miss out on a lot of great things. One of these great things being Tom ************* Bombadil!

#148 to #76 - anon id: 54d8cb97

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

So sad when they didnt include him in the movies

#86 to #76 - joehue

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

Take out the 'read' in that second sentence.
It's almost 4 am, I'm tired.

#66 to #39 - bulbakip

Reply+2

(05/04/2013)[-]

I too read the hobbit, loved it. Read the LotR, not so awesome, difficult to follow. Watched the LotR, ******* tits awesome! Watched the Hobbit, yeah not so much as tits awesome. Maybe it was that 48 frames per second stuff, not a big fan.

(also, 1977 animated Hobbit is tits awesome)

#58 to #39 - matterhornnn

Reply-1

(05/04/2013)[-]

Hobbit wasn't part of the LoTR series, ******. I mean ninjer.

#181 to #58 - ninjastarthrow

Reply0

(05/05/2013)[-]

Yes it is. He almost just went with The Hobbit.

#84 to #58 - ljxjlos

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

The Hobbit is a part of the lord of the Rings. Just not of the triology. It plays in the same Universe and is the direct prequel. How wouldn´t it be a part of the Universe?

#103 to #84 - elielentir

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

Perhaps he means that the Hobbit is not a part of the Lord of the Rings universe but that it's the other way around. The Lord of the Rings is the sequel to the Lord of the Rings so it would be the Hobbit universe. Then again the first things Tolkien wrote about the Tolkien universe was written in about 1917 way before the rest and parts of that story made it in the Silmarilion so it would be the Silmarilion universe.

#105 to #103 - ljxjlos

Reply+1

(05/04/2013)[-]

Well, to me it´s kinda the Tolkien-Universe, I mean, most of his works played in the same space, in arda, so Silmarillion, The Children of Hurin, The Curse of Feanor, The Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings all belong to the same Universe. But I might be arguing about nothing because I´m tired as hell, so just ignore me:D

#107 to #105 - elielentir

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

I agree especially because there are so many unfinished stories that were never completed by him or his son. These untold tales will forever be a part of only Tolkien's mind, his "universe"

#108 to #107 - ljxjlos

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

Yeah, I´m pissed everytime I think about how much more awesome Stuff he could have given us, if he lived longer...as douchebag-ish as it sounds, it´s true. Do you have the Unfinished Tales books? If these stories would have been perfected and finished...goddamnit.

#173 to #108 - elielentir

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

I'm reading it again right now and even this is just a selection of his notes

#176 to #173 - ljxjlos

Reply0

(05/04/2013)[-]

Sorry, if I misunderstanding what you´re saying, I just came home from a party, but does that in any way opposite what I said? Especially because it´s just a selection of notes, short stories and letters, it´s making me sad that those ideas won´t be used in another big story/book/whatever.

#179 to #176 - elielentir

Reply0

(05/05/2013)[-]

No i agree with you completely