Upload
YouTube Videos
Funny Pictures
Funny GIFs
Funny Text
Funny Movies
Login or register
Your Posts
Login or register
Login / Create Account
Create Account
Email is optional and is used for password recovery purposes.
Click to Create Account
Login to FJ
reset password
Stay logged in
Click to Login
Log in/Sign with Facebook.
Log in/Sign up with Gmail.
Create Channel
animemanga
4chan
Tumblr-Content
aww
cat
WholesomeMemes
vidyagaems
politics
starwars
dccomics
UnlimitFateWorks
dungeons-n-drags
oc-comic-makers
marvel
CartoonGoodness
cute
twitter
Daily-Jokes
animals
s-c-p
joshingtime
FJNN
DankHistory
OneForAll
videogames
furry
NegativeFrames
dank-webms
zootopia
polandball
pokemon
Raven
zawarldo
criticalrole
Healthyandstro
dank-meemz
cringe-channel
warhammer40k
tf2
Earth-chan
Remaining character count: 4000
Spoiler Image
[ + ]
Image or Video File:
Shortcuts: "C" opens comments. "R" refreshes comments.
Record voice message?
0:00
Click to start recording.
Enter Captcha Code:
Scroll to comment?
Back to the content 'LotR: Just logical people'
Refresh
Options
asd
2
new threads.
1
new replies.
#3
-
plainarcane
**User deleted account**
Reply
+73
(05/03/2013)
[-]
If you actually watched the movie you'd know that they had no other choice but to take the mines.
#140
to #3
-
anon
id:
cbf34fcb
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Blatantly untrue, at least in the movie. The decision was between Moria and the Gap of Rohan, the problem with the Gap being that it took them "too close to Isengard". But seeing as they eventually fought the Uruk-Hai anyways, without Gandalf, that ended up being of little concern.
But yes, I imagine if Gandalf had mentioned the armies of goblins and the giant fire demon then Frodo might have chosen the Gap.
#106
to #3
-
erethilful
Reply
-2
(05/04/2013)
[-]
If you actually think logically, you'd know that they would use those birds to fly into mordor.
#44
to #3
-
anon
id:
1309590a
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
(what about the eagles flying them?)
#25
to #3
-
beren
[OP]
Reply
+2
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Bitch do you SEE my profile name?
#48
to #25
-
elielentir
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
where's Luthien?
#118
to #48
-
beren
[OP]
Reply
+1
(05/04/2013)
[-]
There has been no Luthien. At least, not since the accident...
#172
to #118
-
elielentir
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Yeah sorry about the hand...
#83
to #48
-
ljxjlos
Reply
+3
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Well, If Beren had spent all his time on the Internet instead of wandering the woods, stealing Silmaril and all this Stuff, like this Beren here, there would be no Luthien for him.
#7
to #3
-
Awesomenessniss
Reply
+31
(05/04/2013)
[-]
If you actually read the book you'd know that even better.
#92
to #7
-
xzynth
Reply
+12
(05/04/2013)
[-]
I wish I could..
#53
to #7
-
clockworkmage
Reply
+1
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Every time someone reads the original book, Christopher Tolkien murders a son as tribute to the Sun god.
#143
to #53
-
Awesomenessniss
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Totally worth it.
#39
to #7
-
ninjastarthrow
Reply
+4
(05/04/2013)
[-]
No one read the books. I have four friends who enjoy LoTR but I'm the only one who ever read them all. Not gonna lie, The Hobbit was my favorite.
#122
to #39
-
cyanidesandvich
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
i haven't "read" the books, but i listen to the unabridged audio-book whilst playing WoW
#76
to #39
-
joehue
Reply
+7
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Agreed, I mean a lot of people have read the books
(Still very popular)
, but a good chunk that watched the movies haven't read even touched the books.
It's a shame too since they miss out on a lot of great things. One of these great things being Tom ************* Bombadil!
#148
to #76
-
anon
id:
54d8cb97
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
So sad when they didnt include him in the movies
#86
to #76
-
joehue
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Take out the 'read' in that second sentence.
It's almost 4 am, I'm tired.
#66
to #39
-
bulbakip
Reply
+2
(05/04/2013)
[-]
I too read the hobbit, loved it. Read the LotR, not so awesome, difficult to follow. Watched the LotR, ******* tits awesome! Watched the Hobbit, yeah not so much as tits awesome. Maybe it was that 48 frames per second stuff, not a big fan.
(also, 1977 animated Hobbit is tits awesome)
#58
to #39
-
matterhornnn
Reply
-1
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Hobbit wasn't part of the LoTR series, ******. I mean ninjer.
#181
to #58
-
ninjastarthrow
Reply
0
(05/05/2013)
[-]
Yes it is. He almost just went with The Hobbit.
#84
to #58
-
ljxjlos
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
The Hobbit is a part of the lord of the Rings. Just not of the triology. It plays in the same Universe and is the direct prequel. How wouldn´t it be a part of the Universe?
#103
to #84
-
elielentir
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Perhaps he means that the Hobbit is not a part of the Lord of the Rings universe but that it's the other way around. The Lord of the Rings is the sequel to the Lord of the Rings so it would be the Hobbit universe. Then again the first things Tolkien wrote about the Tolkien universe was written in about 1917 way before the rest and parts of that story made it in the Silmarilion so it would be the Silmarilion universe.
#105
to #103
-
ljxjlos
Reply
+1
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Well, to me it´s kinda the Tolkien-Universe, I mean, most of his works played in the same space, in arda, so Silmarillion, The Children of Hurin, The Curse of Feanor, The Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings all belong to the same Universe. But I might be arguing about nothing because I´m tired as hell, so just ignore me:D
#107
to #105
-
elielentir
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
I agree especially because there are so many unfinished stories that were never completed by him or his son. These untold tales will forever be a part of only Tolkien's mind, his "universe"
#108
to #107
-
ljxjlos
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Yeah, I´m pissed everytime I think about how much more awesome Stuff he could have given us, if he lived longer...as douchebag-ish as it sounds, it´s true. Do you have the Unfinished Tales books? If these stories would have been perfected and finished...goddamnit.
#173
to #108
-
elielentir
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
I'm reading it again right now and even this is just a selection of his notes
#176
to #173
-
ljxjlos
Reply
0
(05/04/2013)
[-]
Sorry, if I misunderstanding what you´re saying, I just came home from a party, but does that in any way opposite what I said? Especially because it´s just a selection of notes, short stories and letters, it´s making me sad that those ideas won´t be used in another big story/book/whatever.
#179
to #176
-
elielentir
Reply
0
(05/05/2013)
[-]
No i agree with you completely
Back to the content 'LotR: Just logical people'
Top in 24 Hours
Great Restaurant Service
816
5h ago
EMT Cat
1439
8h ago
Duck loves her human.
581
5h ago
me irl
549
4h ago
"Mad White Boys"
913
5h ago
Longevity of a Wookie...
741
6h ago
satisfying piquant hushed Mods
863
7h ago
It's Jenga time!
532
5h ago
Zelda Economics Are Wack Yo
793
7h ago
More good boys
142
2h ago
Cats Will Be Cats (Confinement
408
2h ago
Choose Your Fighter!
649
5h ago
Hello, is this the KGB? No, this is Patrick!
1372
9h ago
woah
782
7h ago
Pokemon League
375
4h ago
Stuff #233
247
2h ago
Secret IP Address
477
5h ago
Riskrem
542
7h ago
Nani?
335
4h ago
Great memory but lacks practice.
1108
9h ago
GOT IT! Dont got it. GOT IT! Don't got it.
65
1h ago
Dennywise
324
4h ago
Hearing
563
7h ago
straight unsightly Rail
870
7h ago
R2Dbirb
610
8h ago
second-hand spurious Squid
1101
9h ago
Diabeetus
1182
9h ago
When your favorite anime ends
129
2h ago
Braille
1313
10h ago
Med School
397
5h ago
Careful...Careful..HUG
511
8h ago
This guy...
350
5h ago
Nappa
1059
10h ago
i call it, mister and missus Tenorman chili
542
7h ago
When you’re tired of Tony's ----
666
7h ago
haha random title xddd
228
4h ago
pricey placid Sandpiper
383
6h ago
scientific furry Kouprey
526
7h ago
puzzling vagabond tame Ape
780
8h ago
Mah heart,mah sole
1120
10h ago