Do You Love Me?. . Another anniversary... Why did this have to happen? Could... could I have stopped you What kind of from becoming Nightmare Moon? sister am I? ponies comic

Do You Love Me?

Tags: ponies | comic
Another anniversary...
Why did this have to happen?
Could... could I have stopped you What kind of
from becoming Nightmare Moon? sister am I? .
Power to raise
the moon and
to save my own
Or was I too weak?
But... almost
knows I try, .
So maybe Idon' t
have to
  • Recommend tagsx
Views: 15636
Favorited: 25
Submitted: 11/13/2012
Share On Facebook
Add to favorites Subscribe to shinigamigod Subscribe to ponytime submit to reddit


shinigamigod has disabled anonymous comments.
#5 - itroitnyah (11/13/2012) [-]
Horn, go home. You are drunk.
#4 - johnnyferno (11/13/2012) [-]
Comment Picture
User avatar #9 to #8 - sparkyoneonetwo (11/14/2012) [-]
b-b-but I already said "THE END"
User avatar #10 to #9 - marconde (11/14/2012) [-]
the end has been doubled
User avatar #12 to #10 - sparkyoneonetwo (11/14/2012) [-]
but you can't do that
User avatar #16 to #14 - sparkyoneonetwo (11/14/2012) [-]
no not new... I just have a fondness for logic
#17 to #16 - pyrocrisis (11/14/2012) [-]
But this is the internet. Logic has no place here. Applesauce cumquwat zipper fry
But this is the internet. Logic has no place here. Applesauce cumquwat zipper fry
User avatar #18 to #17 - sparkyoneonetwo (11/14/2012) [-]
Applesauce cumquwat zipper fry

that sounds oddly delicious
User avatar #32 to #31 - sparkyoneonetwo (11/14/2012) [-]
ah that explains so much
User avatar #20 to #18 - pyrocrisis (11/14/2012) [-]
Still not as good as a hexa-flexa-mexa-gon.
User avatar #11 to #9 - pyrocrisis (11/14/2012) [-]
Their is no end. Stuff happens after you say "the end".
User avatar #15 to #11 - sparkyoneonetwo (11/14/2012) [-]
but after "the end" you start a new story can't change the end of an old one
User avatar #19 to #15 - pyrocrisis (11/14/2012) [-]
But the old story didn't end. You just continued into another plot related to the first one
User avatar #21 to #19 - sparkyoneonetwo (11/14/2012) [-]
but I said the end... that mean the end ......
User avatar #23 to #21 - pyrocrisis (11/14/2012) [-]
But there is no end
User avatar #24 to #23 - sparkyoneonetwo (11/14/2012) [-]
there clearly two of them now
User avatar #25 to #24 - pyrocrisis (11/14/2012) [-]
There are two possible "endings" (after which stuff still happens, we just don't write about it), just like video games with moral choice systems.
User avatar #26 to #25 - sparkyoneonetwo (11/14/2012) [-]
but, like I said after the end it ends the story you then start a new one even if stop happens after then end that's just the start of something new
User avatar #27 to #26 - pyrocrisis (11/14/2012) [-]
Oh I see what you're getting at. by end, you mean a division between two separate but related stories, not a literal ending of existence or time or whatever.
User avatar #28 to #27 - sparkyoneonetwo (11/14/2012) [-]
yeah that's what I mean... I'm just not always that good at saying what I mean in the best way
#7 - lmorriazh (11/13/2012) [-]
this one went right to the feels in me!!
this one went right to the feels in me!!
#2 - flutter **User deleted account** has deleted their comment [-]
#36 - kempsishere (11/14/2012) [-]
anyone else see a straw coming out of celestia instead of her horn?
User avatar #42 to #36 - jonnyp (11/14/2012) [-]
i noticed that Lunas horn in the picture is off-center.
#37 to #36 - lazylazarus (11/14/2012) [-]
That comment ruined the chance of me obtaining a feel
#3 - dashgamer (11/13/2012) [-]
#35 - sparkofinsanity (11/14/2012) [-]
So many feels, it hurts
#6 - xluna (11/13/2012) [-]
love your loved one will you have the chance because in the end they turn again
#39 - cweepew (11/14/2012) [-]
b-b-but i don't want to live on the moon
b-b-but i don't want to live on the moon
User avatar #38 - tireyhawnuyu (11/14/2012) [-]
This is their god damned feel comic I'vee seen in a row. I'm running out of tears.
#40 - tariv (11/14/2012) [-]
Celelestia's face when
Celelestia's face when
User avatar #13 - marconde (11/14/2012) [-]
So... Celestia used the elements of harmony to bring Nightmare Moon to the moon
but Twilight and co. made her good...

why she didn't think about make Luna good again?
User avatar #22 to #13 - jacencaedus ONLINE (11/14/2012) [-]
there are lot's of theories behind that, some say she didn't know how to fully use them, some say they are more powerful when separated into 6 Ponies and used together, I know of one that says that NMM's time on the moon weakened her enough that the elements were then able to free Luna. It's likely that the canon explanation will occur when the Celestia and Luna history episode airs
User avatar #30 to #13 - pyrocrisis (11/14/2012) [-]
She needed Luna to use the full capacity of the Elements of Harmony. Twilight and her friends however, did not
#34 to #13 - brisineo (11/14/2012) [-]
My own personal theory is that Celestia wanted originally to cure Luna and bring her back from the getgo, but because she and Luna were both bearers, she could not use them to their full power. She did the next best thing with what powers the Elements could grant her, which was to banish Nightmare Moon to sever their connections to the Elements, (as them turning against each other would basically destroy the harmony that the Elements originally bond to) and to buy time.

Given the next millennium to plan, she probably sought and researched diligently and manipulated events to make the transition as smooth as possible. She allows Ponyville, a town next to the Everfree which houses the castle in which Nightmare Moon most likely was originally banished, to be founded, then years later, opens a school for Gifted Unicorns, and eventually finds a young filly who excels in magic. Knowing the place Nightmare Moon will return, she sends her student there to "make some friends." (Probably having intel on the ponies who she would encounter beforehand, and placing them in positions of responsibility so Twilight would interact with them)

Knowing that Nightmare Moon would be weakened and would try to regain strength in the old Castle of the Royal Sisters in the Everfree, she let Twilight become interested enough in the Elements to chase after them, letting her find the friendships needed to power the elements, Luna is changed back, and everypony wins. Thus Celestia doesn't have to raise a hoof and she now has her sister back with new bearers of the Elements as a line of defense against the sudden storm of chaos that Nightmare Moon's return somehow caused. (As you can see, whatever crap was going on a thousand years ago suddenly stopped when Nightmare Moon was banished, but then started coming back when she returned)
User avatar #41 - justanotherzombie (11/14/2012) [-]
This made me think of this song
 Friends (0)